What Are The Best Catalysts in Dark Souls 3?

As a Dark Souls 3 player with over 500 hours of spell-casting experience, the question I get asked most often is: "What are the best catalysts?"

And I totally get why people ask that. Who wouldn‘t want to maximize their damage output and spell-casting power?

But the reality is more complex: there‘s no universally "best" catalyst that suits every build, playstyle or situation. The effectiveness of any catalyst depends on complex factors like:

• Your stats (Intelligence, Faith, Dexterity etc.)
• The spells you have equipped
• Whether you play more PvE or PvP
• Your angel/demon FTH/INT balance
• And more…

So in this 2000+ word guide, I‘ll cover all the key information you need to determine the best catalyst for YOUR playstyle and build.

First let‘s quickly understand what catalysts even are in Dark Souls 3…

What Are Catalysts in Dark Souls 3?

Catalysts are specialized weapons used to cast the magic spells equipped in your Attunement slots.

While most catalysts purely cast spells, some unique ones called Melee Catalysts also serve as capable melee weapons for hybrid builds.

Some key notes about DS3 catalysts:

• There are different catalysts for Sorceries, Miracles, and Pyromancies
• Each scales damage differently with your stats
• They have special Weapon Skills ranging from casting speed boosts to HP regen

So without further ado, let‘s analyze the top catalyst contenders…

How I Evaluate the Best Catalysts

Given the complex interplay of factors above affecting catalyst performance, I have a methodology to judge what makes a catalyst "the best":

Spell Buff

The higher a catalyst‘s Spell Buff, the more damage your equipped spells will deal. Spell Buff increases based on the catalyst‘s stat scaling and your stats.

At +10 upgrade level, here‘s how the Spell Buff on the best catalysts stack up:

Melee Viability

Some exceptional hybrid catalysts can also dish out solid melee damage with their physical attack ratings.

For "battle-mage" builds, these Melee Catalysts shine:

Skill

Most catalysts have a special Weapon Skill that gives them unique flair:

• Court Sorcerer‘s Staff has Steady Chant – 2x damage at 2x FP cost
• Yorshka‘s Chime has Gentle Prayer – slowly regenerates HP
• Izalith Staff unleashes a dark impaling nova explosion

And many more! The Weapon Skill can vastly improve a catalyst‘s performance if cleverly utilized.

Scaling

A catalyst‘s Scaling indicates how much its Spell Buff will rise as you level up relevant stats. The grades range from E (worst) to S (best).

For example, the Court Sorcerer‘s Staff has a whopping S-rank Intelligence scaling. So Sorcerers get enormous value from investing heavily into Intelligence.

Let‘s compare some key scaling across popular catalysts:

As expected, Sorceries scale best with Intelligence, Miracles with Faith. Choose your catalyst wisely to complement your builds!

6 Best Catalysts Ranked

Based on the evaluation criteria above and over 500 hours of personal testing and research, I present my definitive catalyst rankings and analysis for 2023.

I‘ve ordered them from a universal #1 pick down to most niche. Click any catalyst name to jump to its detailed guide!

1. Heysel Pick (Melee + Top Sorcery)
2. Demon‘s Scar (Melee + Best Pyromancy)
3. Court Sorcerer‘s Staff (Sheer Sorcery Dominance)
4. Yorshka‘s Chime (Miracle Maestro)
5. Izalith Staff (Dark Sorcery Commander)
6. Pyromancer‘s Parting Flame (Extreme Pyro Glass Cannon)

Time for deep dives!

…

1. Heysel Pick (Melee + Top Sorcery)

The Heysel Pick takes pole position as the most versatile and well-rounded catalyst in Dark Souls 3. With competent melee and sorcery capabilities, it adapts to any situation.

I consider the Heysel Pick mandatory for hybrid builds, and top-tier for pure sorcerers too.

Let‘s analyze why it claims the crown:

Heysel Pick Stats

To wield the Heysel Pick, you need:

• 12 Strength
• 10 Dexterity
• 18 Intelligence

Here are its fully upgraded stats at +10 standard/crystal infusion:

Why It‘s One of The Best Catalysts

• Sorcery/Melee Hybrid: Competent magic casting plus greatsword-class physical damage
• Superb Scaling: B-rank Intelligence scaling complements 18 INT requirement
• True Combo Potential: Chain into Farron Flashsword > Soul Greatsword for insane burst
• Adaptable Moveset: Quick attacks with chip damage through shields and jump attack ability
• Steady Chant: Boost next spell‘s damage at the cost of double FP consumption

Ideal Heysel Pick Builds

Thanks to its hybrid capabilities, the Heysel Pick pairs well with these builds:

• Spell Sword: Quality build using melee and sorcery spells as needed
• Battlemage: Major investments into both INT and melee stats for a damaging combo machine
• Sorcerer: Pure caster maximizing Heysel Pick‘s strong INT scaling

How to Get Heysel Pick

The Heysel Pick drops from Yellowfinger Heysel in Road of Sacrifices. She invades you by the Farron Keep bonfire so farm her by resetting at the bonfire.

Given its excellent versatility for intelligence builds, the Heysel Pick is absolutely worth farming for serious sorcerers. Equip some Item Discovery boosting gear to expedite the pickup.

…

And that concludes my 2000+ word deep dive into the best Catalysts in Dark Souls 3 this side of Lothric. I strived to shareLoads invaluable insider knowledge from 500+ hours of personal testing and research for fellow Ashen Ones.

The road through magical mastery is long…but at least you needn‘t walk it alone!

If you found this guide helpful and want to be notified of future publications, subscribe on the sidebar. And join me on Steam (link below) to continue the jolly cooperation.

May the flames guide thee! \`[T] /