31
Mar
My First Two Weeks with the Amazon Kindle 2
I’m just documenting a few notes here that will hopefully be of benefit to someone.
No Page Numbers!
It probably comes as no surprise to my readers that I am goal oriented. I set goals and carefully track my progress. Reading is no exception. When I’m reading a printed book and I start a new chapter, I will flip forward to see what page the next chapter starts on and then mentally calculate how many pages I have left in the current chapter as I read and turn pages. I used the eReader ebook reader on Palm handhelds for many years and I loved that it always showed the page number I was on and I could easily access the starting page for the next chapter. eReader would recalculate the page numbers if I changed fonts or font size.
This is one of those things that bugs me about the Kindle 2. It does show your progress through the book at the bottom and it shows little dots on the progress bar where the chapter breaks are. Instead of page numbers though, it displays something called Locations. For example, in the book I’m reading now, it has a total of 4945 of these locations. The page I’m on now is displaying Locations 3505-12 (this means Locations 3505 to 3512; I don’t know why it feels it has to truncate the second number). If I push the 5-way controller to the right I can see that the first page for the next chapter displays “Locations 3600-3604″; I don’t know why it doesn’t display this as “Locations 3600-12″ to be consistent). Then I press the back button to go back to where I was. So, in my head I have to subtract 3505 from 3600 to get that I have 95 locations to read. I don’t know exactly what a location is and the number displayed per screen, or page, isn’t consistent. I find this very frustrating.
A Few Features I Would REALLY Like to See:
- AutoScroll: I don’t know it this is possible or practical with the Kindles’ electronic paper technology, but it would be nice to have the text scroll. With this feature, a reader wouldn’t have to press the Next Pagebutton, but the words would just automatically scroll up the screen. This is another of the features from eReader on the Palm and Pocket PC that I really like.
- Rapid Serial Visual Presentation: This feature would add Zap Reader like speed reading functionality to the Kindle. Once again, it may not be possible with the electronic paper technology.
- Menu Wrapping: The Kindle 2 doesn’t have wrapping menus. This means, for example, that if I’m on the Home menu and want to go to the Experimental option that I have to push the 5-way button down 4 times. If it had wrapping menus, I could just push it up 3 times. For many longer menus, this is rather frustrating.
- A General Notepad: Although I can write notes on the Kindle and they are labeled with the location in the book I was reading when I made the notes, there is no way to just write notes. For example, as I read, I get a lot of ideas of things to add to my Task list, or general notes for myself that aren’t about the book I’m reading (even though the book may have inspired the thought or idea). I guess I could create my own little custom book with some custom headings and add notes there, but it seems a little clumsy when I really just want a basic notepad.
- MP3 Tools: I understand that the MP3 player is an experimental feature, but it’s incredibly basic. I know that Amazon wasn’t trying to create an iPod killer with the device, but I think they could greatly increase adoption by improving the MP3 player. Right now you can’t see the titles of MP3 files or your progress through them. This makes it useless for MP3 audio books. It’s probably similar to using an iPod Shuffle. It’s probably only useful for some music that you like to listen to as background music while you read.
It’s Great for Reading on Planes!
I did have a few plane trips in the last couple weeks. I will admit that the Kindle is an absolutely wonderful way to read when you are scrunched up in an airplane seat. You don’t need to move your whole arm to turn a page, it very small and light so it’s a pleasure to hold and fits well in the seat back pocket. I was just surprised that no one asked me about it, even my seat mates. On the down-side, however, you probably can’t read on it during take off and landing, even though the device is only turned on when you turn a page. Hopefully this will change as airlines get more comfortable with electronic devices and the electronic paper becomes more popular.
Kindle Usability
If you don’t regularly Jakob Nielsen’s Alertbox articles, you may not be aware of two articles he wrote recently: Kindle 2 Usability Review and Kindle Content Design. These are well worth reading.

